The Hospitality Newsletter
Today Saturday, September 12, 2026

The Hospitality Newsletter

· Role

Hospitality News for General Managers

Hospitality industry news curated for general managers — filtered for what matters to the role: p&L impact, guest satisfaction scores, operational efficiency, competitive positioning, staff retention, and revenue per available room.

What we filter for: P&L impact, guest satisfaction scores, operational efficiency, competitive positioning, staff retention, and revenue per available room.

📊

General Manager — Market Analysis

2303 stories

U.S. RevPAR jumped 16.1% as aging room stock triggers a record pipeline of 2,097 asset renovations.

📈

Revenue Growth ·U.S. RevPAR gained 16.1% in its 21st consecutive week of growth, led by Minneapolis occupancy and Las Vegas room rates.

📊

Capital Expenditure ·2,097 projects and 255,834 rooms sit in the U.S. renovation pipeline as 5,000 properties reach reinvestment age.

💵

Utility Drag ·Static thermostat schedules cost hoteliers millions in peak demand charges as rising electricity rates squeeze operating margins.

💻

Discovery Shift ·AI-driven discovery referrals surged 194%, bypassing traditional search engines and altering direct booking acquisition paths.

Outlook

Proposed UK tourist taxes and DHS visa rule changes will test international demand and staffing flexibility next quarter.

Latest Stories

2303 stories
Google Revamps European Hotel Search Under EU Pressure
marketingSkift··1 min·For: Owner, GM, Revenue, Marketing

Google Revamps European Hotel Search Under EU Pressure

Google has redesigned its hotel search interface across Europe to comply with EU antitrust regulations, introducing dedicated sections for both aggregators and direct suppliers.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1New interface separates results into direct 'supplier' and OTA 'aggregator' units
  2. 2Top-ranked OTA results expand by default in the new aggregator section
  3. 3Design changes aim to avoid severe antitrust penalties from European Union regulators
Trump Proposes Ending 60-Day H-1B Grace Period
hrasianhospitality.com··1 min·For: Owner, GM, Ops, IT

Trump Proposes Ending 60-Day H-1B Grace Period

A new Department of Homeland Security proposal seeks to eliminate the 60-day grace period for H-1B and other specialty visa holders after their employment ends. The policy change would require laid-off foreign workers to depart immediately, tightening corporate offboarding timelines.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1DHS proposal eliminates the 60-day post-employment departure window for H-1B, L-1, and E-category visas
  2. 2HR teams would face compressed offboarding timelines with foreign staff required to leave immediately upon job loss
  3. 3Follows previous executive actions including major visa fee hikes aimed at prioritizing domestic workers
U.S. Hotel Renovations Reach Record 2,097 Projects
operationsHotel Business··1 min·For: Owner, GM, Investor

U.S. Hotel Renovations Reach Record 2,097 Projects

A record 2,097 projects and 255,834 rooms are in the U.S. renovation and conversion pipeline as over 5,000 hotels built between 2006 and 2011 reach critical reinvestment age. Texas, Florida, and California lead the aging supply concentration, driving owners to update aging tech and finishes.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1Over 5,180 U.S. hotels (572,494 rooms) are now 15-20 years old, creating a wave of unavoidable major renovations.
  2. 2The current renovation and conversion pipeline stands at an all-time high of 2,097 projects and 255,834 rooms.
  3. 3Texas leads the aging inventory with 838 properties, followed by Florida (371) and California (301).
U.S. Hotel RevPAR Surges 16% in 21st Week of Growth
financeLodging Magazine··1 min·For: Owner, GM, Revenue, Investor

U.S. Hotel RevPAR Surges 16% in 21st Week of Growth

The U.S. hotel industry marked its 21st consecutive week of year-over-year gains, driven by a 16.1% RevPAR increase aided by the Labor Day calendar shift. Major markets saw varied performance, led by Minneapolis in occupancy gains and Las Vegas in rate growth.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1RevPAR increased 16.1% to $100.31, with occupancy up 9.4% to 63% and ADR up 6.1% to $159.19.
  2. 2Minneapolis led top markets with RevPAR up 35.7%, while Las Vegas posted a 24.8% ADR surge.
  3. 3St. Louis suffered the steepest declines across all metrics, with RevPAR falling 11.8%.
AI Referrals Surge 194% as Hotel Discovery Evolves
technologyLodging Magazine··1 min·For: Marketing, Revenue, GM, Owner

AI Referrals Surge 194% as Hotel Discovery Evolves

Conversational AI is transforming travel inspiration by providing hyper-curated recommendations instead of traditional search pages. To capture demand, hotels must develop strong local identities and distinct programming that AI tools can easily interpret and recommend.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1AI referrals to travel sites jumped 194% year over year, with 89% of consumers wanting to use AI for trip planning.
  2. 2Travelers increasingly query AI using specific preferences and occasions rather than generic star-rating searches.
  3. 3Distinct property programming and neighborhood integration create the digital footprint needed to secure AI recommendations.
England Advances Plans for Uncapped Hotel Tourist Tax
financeBoutique Hotel News··1 min·For: Owner, GM, Revenue, Investor

England Advances Plans for Uncapped Hotel Tourist Tax

The UK government is preparing legislation granting regional mayors the power to levy an uncapped tax on hotel and short-term rental stays. Expected to take effect around 2028, the proposal faces strong pushback from industry leaders warning of reduced demand and job losses.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1New legislation will allow English mayors to introduce local overnight accommodation levies with no national price cap.
  2. 2London is reportedly considering a percentage-based levy of up to 5%, with revenues reserved for local infrastructure and services.
  3. 3UKHospitality warns that a 5% nationwide levy could cost 33,000 jobs and decrease economic activity by £2 billion.
Hyatt Partners with Delta on Reciprocal Loyalty Program
marketingHotel Dive··1 min·For: Marketing, Revenue, GM, Owner

Hyatt Partners with Delta on Reciprocal Loyalty Program

Hyatt Hotels has launched a long-term loyalty partnership with Delta Air Lines offering reciprocal earning benefits, replacing its previous tie-up with American Airlines. The collaboration allows elite members of both programs to earn hotel points and airline miles across stays and flights.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1Eligible World of Hyatt elites will earn points on Delta flights, while SkyMiles Medallion members will earn miles on Hyatt stays.
  2. 2The move directly follows Hyatt's decision to terminate its loyalty partnership with American Airlines.
  3. 3World of Hyatt membership grew 17% year-over-year to reach 69 million members in Q2 2026.
IHG Signs 15-Hotel Deal to Debut Staybridge in Australia
financeeHotelier··1 min·For: Owner, Investor, GM, Revenue

IHG Signs 15-Hotel Deal to Debut Staybridge in Australia

IHG Hotels & Resorts has partnered with developer ALAND to introduce Staybridge Suites to Australia via a 15-hotel, 2,000-room master development agreement. The initial rollout features two franchise properties in Greater Western Sydney managed by Signature Hotel Management Group.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1ALAND secures exclusive development rights for at least 15 Staybridge Suites across Australia
  2. 2First two properties confirmed: 130-room Sydney Parramatta and 112-room Sydney Leppington
  3. 3The move targets surging demand from corporate travelers and project-based extended stays
Canadian Travel to U.S. Rises 8.8% Despite Trade Tensions
marketingSkift··1 min·For: GM, Revenue, Owner, Marketing

Canadian Travel to U.S. Rises 8.8% Despite Trade Tensions

Canadian travel to the U.S. grew for a fifth consecutive month in August, rising 8.8% year-over-year despite ongoing trade tensions. However, overall cross-border volume remains more than 22% below 2024 levels.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1Return trips by Canadian residents rose 8.8% year-over-year in August, marking five months of gains.
  2. 2Automobile travel increased 9.9% while air arrivals grew 3.6% compared to the previous year.
  3. 3Total visits remain depressed compared to 2024, with car trips down 27.4% and air travel down 22.7%.
OYO Parent PRISM Targets $700M IPO to Clear Debt
financeasianhospitality.com··1 min·For: Investor, Owner, GM

OYO Parent PRISM Targets $700M IPO to Clear Debt

OYO parent company PRISM plans to launch a $700 million IPO this fiscal year, using approximately $525 million of the fresh proceeds to pay down debt. The move follows strong financial performance, with fiscal 2026 net profit surging fourfold to $104 million led by North American growth.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1PRISM plans a $700M all-fresh-issue IPO this fiscal year with no offer-for-sale component.
  2. 2Roughly $525M of the proceeds will be allocated directly toward repaying outstanding borrowings.
  3. 3Net profit rose more than fourfold to $104M in fiscal 2026, driven largely by North American expansion.
Middle East Tourism Recovery Stalls as Index Drops to 94
financeSkift··1 min·For: Owner, GM, Revenue, Investor

Middle East Tourism Recovery Stalls as Index Drops to 94

The Skift Travel Health Index for the Middle East and Africa plunged from full recovery in June to 94 in July amid renewed security concerns and flight disruptions. The downturn has weakened traveler confidence and pricing power across the region, though vacation rentals showed resilience.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1Regional travel index fell from 100 in June to 94 in July due to travel advisories and flight suspensions
  2. 2Accommodation providers face reduced booking conversions and pressure on pricing power
  3. 3Vacation rentals was the sole outperforming segment, rising 14% year-over-year
Static Smart Thermostats Cost Hotels Millions in Surging Energy Costs
sustainabilityLodging Magazine··1 min·For: Owner, GM, Ops, IT

Static Smart Thermostats Cost Hotels Millions in Surging Energy Costs

Outdated, static smart thermostat schedules fail to protect hotels from volatile utility rates and peak demand charges driven by grid strain. Hoteliers must adopt dynamic energy controls that adjust in real time to occupancy, weather, and grid pricing.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1Guestroom HVAC accounts for over one-third of a hotel's total energy spend, which averages over $3,000 per room annually.
  2. 2Less than 10% of hotels use smart guestroom energy controls, and many run on years-old static programming that misses peak-pricing events.
  3. 3Dynamic systems that monitor occupancy and utility signals enable pre-cooling and load shedding, avoiding costly peak demand surcharges without hurting guest comfort.
Hilton Global CMO Mark Weinstein Steps Down
marketingasianhospitality.com··1 min·For: Owner, GM, Marketing, Investor

Hilton Global CMO Mark Weinstein Steps Down

Hilton's global chief marketing officer and head of luxury brands, Mark Weinstein, has stepped down after more than 16 years with the company. An immediate successor has not yet been named to oversee the brand's global marketing and 28 hotel flags.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1Mark Weinstein departs Hilton after serving as global CMO and luxury head across 9,200+ properties.
  2. 2During his tenure, he launched major campaigns including 'Hilton. For the Stay' and grew Hilton Honors tenfold to 250M members.
  3. 3Hilton has not yet named an immediate successor for the global CMO position.
Accor CEO: Data Must Nourish Instinct, Not Replace It
operationsSkift··1 min·For: Owner, GM, Ops, Investor

Accor CEO: Data Must Nourish Instinct, Not Replace It

Accor CEO Sébastien Bazin outlines his leadership philosophy ahead of Skift Global Forum, arguing that while data and AI are vital, human instinct and personal connection remain the ultimate differentiators in hospitality.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1Accor CEO emphasizes that waiting for complete data often leads to delayed, ineffective decision-making.
  2. 2AI will reshape travel discovery, but high-touch human service will become more valuable as a result.
  3. 3Leadership philosophy prioritizes instinct and people over purely analytical, risk-averse strategies.
Outdated HVAC Controls Cost Hotels Millions as Energy Rates Surge
sustainabilityLodging Magazine··1 min·For: Owner, GM, Ops, Investor

Outdated HVAC Controls Cost Hotels Millions as Energy Rates Surge

Static thermostat schedules are eroding hotel profitability as rising electricity rates and grid strain drive up utility costs. Operators must transition to dynamic energy management that actively responds to occupancy, weather, and peak utility pricing.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1Guestroom HVAC accounts for more than a third of a hotel's total energy spend, averaging over $3,000 per room annually.
  2. 2Fewer than 10% of hotels use smart thermostats, and most existing systems run on outdated, static schedules.
  3. 3Dynamic energy controls that respond to real-time grid alerts and occupancy can prevent costly utility demand charges.
Radisson and Lalchand Partner on Two Odisha Hotels
generalasianhospitality.com··1 min·For: Owner, Investor, GM

Radisson and Lalchand Partner on Two Odisha Hotels

Lalchand is developing two new Radisson properties in Odisha, adding 220 keys across Bhubaneswar and Kataka to target commercial and cultural travel demand.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1New 115-room Radisson hotel in Bhubaneswar features 1,200 square meters of MICE space
  2. 2Kataka property adds 105 rooms as the city's first branded resort, with over 1,068 square meters of event facilities
  3. 3The signing expands Radisson Hotel Group's regional footprint in Odisha to six properties
Gulf Hotels Slash Rates by Half Amid Regional Slump
financeSkift··1 min·For: Owner, GM, Revenue, Investor

Gulf Hotels Slash Rates by Half Amid Regional Slump

Gulf hospitality operators are discounting room rates by over 50% to maintain occupancy amid widespread cancellations and heavy lease obligations. Independent operators face an acute survival crisis as government fee deferrals fail to offset fixed costs.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1Dubai operators report discounting extended stays from AED6,500 to AED3,000 to maintain occupancy
  2. 2Mid-sized groups absorb millions in cancellations alongside heavy fixed lease burdens
  3. 3Limited government relief leaves independent operators at higher risk than major brands
DOJ Sues Hotel Operators Over Alleged $100M Fraud
financeasianhospitality.com··1 min·For: Owner, Investor, GM

DOJ Sues Hotel Operators Over Alleged $100M Fraud

The U.S. Department of Justice has filed a massive civil fraud lawsuit against hotel operators Pankaj and Rajan Sheth, accusing them of using shell companies to secure over $100 million in loans despite prior defaults. The complaint alleges a multi-year cycle of deceptive refinancing, bankruptcy delays, and severe operational neglect.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1DOJ civil complaint names hotel operators, relatives, and 21 entities in an alleged $100M fraud scheme
  2. 2Operators allegedly used straw owners and shell firms to conceal past defaults and secure federally guaranteed loans
  3. 3Properties suffered from understaffing, funding shortages, liens, and public nuisance code violations
94% of Hotels Missing from AI Search Results
marketingeHotelier··1 min·For: Marketing, Revenue, GM, Owner

94% of Hotels Missing from AI Search Results

With 75% of event planners sourcing venues through AI tools like ChatGPT, hotels risk losing corporate bookings unless they optimize for large language models. Venues must replace vague marketing with structured, highly specific data regarding meeting room dimensions, AV capacity, and pricing.

Key Takeaways

  1. 194% of hotels fail to appear in AI search queries despite 75% of event planners using AI to source venues.
  2. 2AI chatbots prioritize structured, granular data like floorplans, capacities, and transit links over brand recognition.
  3. 3Venues with comprehensive third-party listings are up to 50% more likely to be cited by AI platforms.
Navan Buys BoomPop to Expand Into Meetings and Events
technologySkift··1 min·For: Revenue, Ops, IT, GM

Navan Buys BoomPop to Expand Into Meetings and Events

Corporate travel platform Navan has acquired AI-powered event management startup BoomPop to integrate venue sourcing, RFPs, and room blocks into its core system. The tool will be rebranded as Navan Events, directly challenging competitors like Cvent amid Navan's 35% year-over-year revenue growth.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1Navan acquired BoomPop for an undisclosed sum, rebranding it as Navan Events with no layoffs planned.
  2. 2BoomPop provides AI-assisted venue sourcing, room block management, RFPs, and event payments.
  3. 3The deal was announced alongside Q2 revenue of $233 million, up 35% year over year.
EU Proposes New Rules to Help Cities Restrict Short-Term Rentals
operationsSkift··1 min·For: Owner, GM, Revenue, Investor

EU Proposes New Rules to Help Cities Restrict Short-Term Rentals

The European Commission has introduced the Affordable Housing Act, providing cities with a legal framework to curb short-term rentals like Airbnb in housing-stressed areas. The proposal aims to tackle soaring housing costs, which have increased by more than 60% across the bloc since 2013.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1New EU legislation establishes a legal roadmap for cities to restrict short-term rentals
  2. 2The framework helps authorities identify areas facing acute housing affordability stress
  3. 3Short-term rental trade groups have raised concerns over a lack of regulatory oversight
Hilton, Loews, and Driftwood Unveil Executive Moves
hrLodging Magazine··1 min·For: Owner, GM, Ops, Investor

Hilton, Loews, and Driftwood Unveil Executive Moves

Major hospitality brands and management groups have announced key executive appointments across investment, regional operations, and property leadership. Notable moves include executive shifts at Hilton, Loews Hotels, PM Hotel Group, and Driftwood Capital.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1Hilton tapped former Ares Management MD Kolin Pound as area president for Caribbean and Latin America.
  2. 2Driftwood Capital named David Resnick and David Steiner as co-CIOs to unify equity and credit investment platforms.
  3. 3Key property and portfolio leadership roles were filled by Loews, Kimpton, The Standard, and Hyatt.
Wyndham to Open First Dolce Hotel in Mississippi
financeLodging Magazine··1 min·For: Owner, Investor, GM

Wyndham to Open First Dolce Hotel in Mississippi

Wyndham Hotels & Resorts has gained approval to develop a 250-room Dolce hotel alongside a new 50,000-square-foot conference center in Ridgeland, Mississippi. The $120 million public-private project marks the upscale brand's debut in the state.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1Madison County approved the $120M Prado Vista project featuring a Dolce hotel and conference facility
  2. 2The privately financed 250-room hotel pairs with a 50,000-square-foot center holding up to 1,800 guests
  3. 3Public-private agreement directs $18.9 million back to the county to accelerate construction debt repayment
Fall Hotel Outlook: Luxury Pipelines and Dining Lead Growth
operationsHotel Dive··1 min·For: Owner, Investor, GM, F&B

Fall Hotel Outlook: Luxury Pipelines and Dining Lead Growth

Hospitality leaders are eyeing key fall trends following a strong summer, driven by luxury segment investments, brand conversions, and dining-led bookings. Investor interest remains heavily concentrated on high-end properties alongside record U.S. construction activity.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1Investors are targeting luxury assets as conversions and upscale builds drive a record U.S. construction pipeline.
  2. 2Food and beverage programs increasingly drive bookings, with 60% of guests choosing hotels specifically for their restaurants.
  3. 3RevPAR gains and portfolio expansions from summer set a positive baseline heading into the fall season.
Luxury Hoteliers Rethink Personalisation Beyond the Buzzword
technologyBoutique Hotel News··1 min·For: GM, Marketing, Ops, IT

Luxury Hoteliers Rethink Personalisation Beyond the Buzzword

Hospitality leaders at a London roundtable urged hotels to bridge disconnected tech stacks to deliver genuine, relevant personalisation. Executives stressed using AI behind the scenes to automate routine tasks, freeing staff to build authentic guest connections.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1Fragmented tech stacks and isolated data profiles leave pre-arrival as hospitality's weakest touchpoint.
  2. 2Hoteliers advocate using AI for operational tasks like reporting and email triage to maximize face-to-face guest time.
  3. 3High staff turnover makes unified guest profile systems essential for retaining service history and stay preferences.
DOJ Sues Hotel Operators in Alleged $100M Fraud Scheme
financeasianhospitality.com··1 min·For: Owner, Investor, GM

DOJ Sues Hotel Operators in Alleged $100M Fraud Scheme

The U.S. Department of Justice has filed a civil fraud complaint against hotel operators Pankaj and Rajan Sheth for allegedly securing over $100 million in loans through shell companies and straw owners. The lawsuit claims the family concealed past bankruptcies, defaults, and property conditions to obtain federally backed debt.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1DOJ filed a 332-page civil complaint accusing the Sheth family of securing over $100M in loans via deceptive practices
  2. 2Operators allegedly used shell entities and straw owners to hide repeat defaults, court judgments, and bankruptcies
  3. 3Hotels tied to the schemes reportedly suffered from underfunding, severe understaffing, and local code violations
Direct Hotel Guests Return at Nearly 4x Rate of OTAs
generaleHotelier··1 min·For: Owner, GM, Revenue, Marketing

Direct Hotel Guests Return at Nearly 4x Rate of OTAs

A study of 2.2 million European hotel guests reveals that direct bookers return at nearly four times the rate of OTA guests while generating 35% higher first-stay revenue. The data highlights a steep retention liability for properties overly dependent on third-party channels.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1Direct-booking guests have a 5.1% return rate compared to just 1.3% for OTA guests.
  2. 2First-stay revenue is 35% higher for direct guests (€379 vs. €280) before factoring in commission costs.
  3. 3Direct-acquired guests account for 68% of repeat stays despite representing only 35% of initial bookings.
Host Spends $105M on Hurricane Repairs at The Don CeSar
financeSkift··1 min·For: Owner, Investor, Ops, GM

Host Spends $105M on Hurricane Repairs at The Don CeSar

Host Hotels & Resorts spent an estimated $105 million to remediate and repair damage at Florida's The Don CeSar following hurricanes Helene and Milton. The disclosure highlights the mounting impact of severe weather events on hotel capital expenditures and resilience investments.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1Host allocated $75 million, or 11.6% of its 2025 total capex, toward hurricane and restoration work
  2. 2The Don CeSar faced prolonged closures through March 2025, offset by $73 million in insurance payouts
  3. 3Host directed approximately 8% of overall capex toward climate resilience initiatives over a six-year span
Cloud5 Acquires interTouch CALA to Expand Tech Reach
technologyLodging Magazine··1 min·For: Owner, GM, Ops, IT

Cloud5 Acquires interTouch CALA to Expand Tech Reach

Cloud5 Communications has signed a definitive agreement to acquire interTouch CALA, expanding its hospitality technology and communications footprint across Mexico, the Caribbean, and Central and South America. The deal enables Cloud5 to deliver managed IT, HSIA, telecoms, and contact center services throughout the Western Hemisphere.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1Cloud5 expands into CALA to follow major hotel client investments in the region.
  2. 2Acquisition adds managed IT, HSIA, PBX telecom, in-room entertainment, and contact center services.
  3. 3Deal is expected to close this month as interTouch refutes CALA to focus on Asia Pacific.
Google Strips EU Travel Search Features Over DMA Rules
marketingSkift··1 min·For: Marketing, Revenue, Owner, GM

Google Strips EU Travel Search Features Over DMA Rules

Google is significantly scaling back its travel search features in the European Union to comply with Digital Markets Act antitrust regulations. The changes remove live pricing filters, split booking channels into separate units, and eliminate the vacation rentals search module entirely.

Key Takeaways

  1. 1Search results in the EU now split into two separate units for third-party aggregators and direct suppliers.
  2. 2EU users lose direct search tools for checking live hotel pricing, filtering dates, or applying descriptive tags.
  3. 3Google is completely removing its dedicated vacation rentals unit from European search results.

Frequently asked

+Why are U.S. hotel renovation projects at a record high?

Over 5,000 U.S. hotels built between 2006 and 2011 have reached critical reinvestment age. As a result, the renovation and conversion pipeline contains a record 2,097 projects and 255,834 rooms. Texas, Florida, and California lead this aging supply concentration, prompting general managers and owners to upgrade aging finishes and technology.

+How does Google's European search update affect hotel listings?

Google redesigned its hotel search interface across Europe to comply with EU antitrust regulations. The updated format introduces dedicated sections specifically separated for direct suppliers and aggregators. General managers with European properties must now navigate distinct placement channels for direct hotel links alongside third-party booking sites.

+How can hotel operators reduce rising utility expenses from HVAC systems?

Hotels must replace static smart thermostat schedules with dynamic energy management controls. Static schedules fail to counter volatile utility rates and peak demand charges caused by grid strain. Dynamic systems reduce costs by adjusting energy output in real time based on property occupancy, local weather patterns, and peak utility pricing.

+How will the proposed Department of Homeland Security H-1B rule change impact hotel staffing?

The Department of Homeland Security proposal eliminates the 60-day grace period for H-1B and specialty visa holders following termination. Terminated foreign workers must depart the country immediately upon ending employment. This policy change will require hotel general managers and HR teams to enforce tighter corporate offboarding timelines.